Brian,
Man, this thread is really jogging some memories of some great times! While in college (75-79) most of my foos time was spent on the Rene Pierre (Bonzini clone) in our dorm and the Dueshter Meister tables at a couple of the local bars. On Christmas break, probably 1977, I found out that my best friend was a good player on TS (first contact with Tournament Soccer), that he actually worked for the company (he is in the Replay 5th anniversary issue - very collectible item) and he had a table in his basement. It was a green top with the DM waffle foot men, one of the early tables. The next winter he had the new and improved blue top with the horizontal grooved men. I remember him saying that TS strengthened the new men by building up the shoulder around the rod and improved control by redesigning the foot and using hard rubber instead of plastic, to make them less brittle and have more reenforcement where they usually started to crack. A couple of years later the brownie came out with the plastic men with hats, and it was pretty cool to see a new table in his basement each time I visited him.
The reason I bring this brief history is that the info he gave me is pretty much my source for my comments in this thread. Now, I really don't know if the DM men, which were definitly used on the early TS tables, were actually made by Dueshter Meister or if DM bought them from the same manufacturer TS did. The waffle foot men have no patent info on them (I checked the 40 or so that I have) so they may or may not have actually been produced by DM - I always have assumed they were but don't really know. I never saw any other type men on DM tables, but that may not answer this question.
As for your experience with breakage, I rarely saw a DM table with broken men but those rods were very light. If memory serves me correctly, my TS friend said that it was the extra torque produced by the solid rods that exposed the weakness in the DM men. When you commented that the DM men were more durable, did you mean on a DM table or TS table?
What would be really fun to play would be a DM table with the TS red & blue guys. The DM table could actually pin better than you'd guess, based on the small contact area of the waffle foot. And LOL to the thoooonk sound - man I miss those good old days! Oh, the more I think about it, the Long Shot table used the red & blue guys because they looked more 'life like'. LOL to your 'realistic' comments! You have a great sense of humor.
Take care............................................Tyler